How to Create a Punch List: Step-by-Step Guide for Contractors
You're two weeks from substantial completion. The owner's final walkthrough is scheduled for Friday. You know there are items to fix - some drywall patches, a few doors that need adjustment, touch-up paint in the lobby - but you don't have a comprehensive list yet.
So you grab a clipboard and start walking the building. You're scribbling notes as fast as you can. "Bathroom 2nd floor men's room -> loose toilet seat." "Lobby -> scratch on reception desk." "Conference room B -> light fixture not level."
By the time you're done, you've got four pages of handwritten notes in your own shorthand that nobody else can read. Half the items don't have room numbers.
A quarter of them are missing who's responsible for fixing them. And you already know you missed stuff because you were rushing.
Sound familiar?
A good punch list isn't just a to-do list. It's the final quality control checkpoint before you hand over the building. It's what keeps you from getting called back three months later because something obvious wasn't caught.
And when done right, it's the difference between a smooth closeout and weeks of back-and-forth with an unhappy owner.
Let's walk through how to create a punch list that works.
What Is a Punch List (And Why It Matters)
A punch list (sometimes called a snag list or deficiency list) is a document that identifies all the work items that need to be completed or corrected before a construction project can be considered finished and ready for final payment.
Think of it as the gap between "we're basically done" and "we're actually done."
Common punch list items include:
- Cosmetic fixes (paint touch-ups, scratched surfaces, stained materials)
- Minor installations (missing hardware, outlet covers, trim pieces)
- Adjustments (doors that don't latch, windows that stick, equipment that needs calibration)
- Cleaning (construction debris, protective film removal, final cleaning)
- Documentation (missing manuals, warranty cards, as-built drawings)
The punch list serves multiple purposes. For contractors, it's your roadmap to final completion and a way to manage subcontractor responsibilities.
For owners, it's their assurance that everything they paid for will actually be delivered. For everyone, it's a clear record of what "complete" means so there's no confusion later.
A thorough punch list prevents the "oh, one more thing" conversations that drag on for months after you thought the project was done.
When to Create Your Punch List
Timing matters. Create your punch list too early and you're documenting issues that haven't even happened yet. Wait too long and you're scrambling to coordinate fixes when subs have already demobilized.
The ideal timing:
Pre-Substantial Completion Walk (Contractor's Internal Walk)
Do your own punch list walk 2-3 weeks before substantial completion. This gives you time to fix obvious issues before the owner sees them.
Your subs are still on site. Materials are available. You can knock out 80% of items before the official walkthrough.
Substantial Completion Walk (Owner/Architect Walk)
This is the formal punch list creation with all project stakeholders—owner, architect, owner's rep, key consultants.
Everyone walks together, identifying items that need completion or correction.
This becomes the official punch list that gates final payment.
Final Completion Walk
After you've completed the punch list items, the owner and architect verify everything is actually done. Ideally, this walk results in zero new items because you caught everything the first time.
Don't wait until the day before the owner's walkthrough to start thinking about punch list items. You won't have time to fix anything, and you'll look unprepared.
Step-by-Step: How to Create an Effective Punch List
Step 1: Organize Your Team and Tools
Before you start walking the building, get organized.
Who should participate:
- Project manager or superintendent (always)
- Key subcontractors (especially finishes trades)
- Your quality control person if you have one
- Foreman or lead carpenter
What to bring:
- Clipboard with blank punch list forms (or tablet/phone with punch list app)
- Camera or smartphone for photos
- Measuring tape for dimensional issues
- Flashlight for inspecting dark areas
- Copy of approved drawings and specs for reference
Pro tip: If you're doing the contractor's internal walk, bring the subs whose work you'll be inspecting. They can often fix minor items on the spot, and they'll have a better sense of what needs to be corrected.
Step 2: Walk the Project Systematically
Don't just wander randomly. Create a logical walking pattern so you don't miss areas.
Common approaches:
- Floor by floor, room by room (works for buildings with repetitive layouts)
- By system (all MEP first, then finishes, then site work)
- By trade (electrical walk, plumbing walk, etc.)
Pick one approach and stick to it. The key is covering 100% of the work scope without duplicating effort or skipping areas.
Areas contractors commonly miss:
- Mechanical rooms and utility spaces
- Roof and above-ceiling areas
- Exterior perimeter and service areas
- Back-of-house spaces (storage, janitor closets, electrical rooms)
- Parking and site amenities
Set aside enough time. A thorough punch list walk on a 50,000 SF building can easily take 4-6 hours. Don't rush it.
Step 3: Document Each Item Clearly and Completely
This is where most punch lists fall apart. Vague descriptions like "fix door" or "paint issues lobby" don't give anyone enough information to actually complete the work.
What every punch list item should include:
Location: Be specific. "2nd Floor, Room 204, North Wall" beats "upstairs somewhere."
Description: Clearly describe the deficiency. "Door closer on main entrance not adjusted. Door slams shut instead of soft close" beats "fix door."
Responsible Party: Note which subcontractor or vendor is responsible. "Overhead Door Co." or "Prime Painting" so there's no confusion about who fixes it.
Photo: A picture eliminates ambiguity. Take a photo of every item when possible.
Spec Reference (if relevant): For items that don't meet specifications, cite the relevant section. "Does not meet Spec 09 91 00 paragraph 2.4 - Paint coverage incomplete."
Example of a good punch list item:
- Item #: 047
- Location: Building A, 3rd Floor, Conference Room 301, East Wall
- Description: Paint coverage incomplete on drywall above door frame. Primer visible through finish coat in 6" x 12" area.
- Responsible Party: ABC Painting
- Spec Reference: Section 09 91 00
- Photo: IMG_2847.jpg
- Status: Open
Example of a bad punch list item:
- Paint problem room 301
See the difference?
Step 4: Categorize Items by Priority
Not all punch list items are created equal. Some affect life safety or building functionality. Others are purely cosmetic.
Common priority levels:
Critical (Must fix before substantial completion):
- Life safety issues (fire alarm deficiencies, emergency lighting)
- Code violations
- Building system failures (HVAC not operational, plumbing leaks)
- Items preventing occupancy
High (Must fix before final completion):
- Functional deficiencies (doors that don't lock, windows that leak)
- Visible cosmetic issues in public areas
- Missing equipment or fixtures
Medium (Should fix before closeout):
- Minor cosmetic issues
- Touch-ups and adjustments
- Items in less-visible areas
Low (Nice to have):
- Very minor imperfections
- Items in back-of-house areas
- Issues that don't affect function or appearance
Categorizing helps you triage. If you've got 200 punch list items and two weeks to close out, you need to know which 50 are actually preventing final payment.
Step 5: Assign Responsibility and Set Deadlines
A punch list without clear ownership and deadlines is just a wish list.
For each item, determine:
- Who's responsible: Specific subcontractor or vendor name, not just "electrical" or "painting." If it's unclear, note it as "TBD - GC to coordinate" and figure it out immediately after the walk.
- Target completion date: Based on the overall closeout schedule. If substantial completion is March 1st, most items should be complete by February 25th to allow time for verification.
- Dependencies: Some items can't be completed until others are done. Note these so you're not waiting on a painter to touch up an area that still needs drywall repair.
Pro tip: Group items by responsible party when you distribute the punch list. Give each sub their own filtered list showing only their items. This makes it easier for them to schedule and complete the work efficiently.
Step 6: Track Completion and Verify Work
Creating the punch list is only half the job. Now you need to manage it through completion.
Best practices for tracking:
Update the punch list regularly (at least twice per week during closeout). Mark items as complete only after you've personally verified the work, not just because a sub says they're done.
Take photos of completed items. This documents that the work was actually done and done correctly.
Don't let new items creep in after the official walk unless they're genuinely new discoveries. The punch list isn't a moving target where the owner keeps adding things they thought of later.
Hold weekly punch list meetings with subs during the closeout phase. Review open items, address obstacles, and keep everyone accountable.
Use color coding or status fields to show progress at a glance:
- Red = Open
- Yellow = In Progress
- Green = Complete
- Blue = Complete and Verified
Step 7: Conduct Final Verification Walk
Once you believe all punch list items are complete, do a final verification walk before bringing the owner and architect back.
Check every single item on the list. Don't assume your subs did the work correctly just because they said it's done. Trust but verify.
If you find items that aren't actually complete or weren't done to spec, get them fixed before the final walk. Nothing frustrates an owner more than a "completed" punch list that still has obvious deficiencies.
When the owner and architect return for final verification:
- Walk through items systematically using the punch list as your guide
- Document any items that still aren't satisfactory
- Address those immediately (ideally same day or next day)
- Get formal sign-off that punch list is complete
Tools That Make Punch List Management Easier
Let's be honest, managing punch lists with paper forms and spreadsheets works, but it's tedious. Photos are in your phone. Notes are on your clipboard.
The spreadsheet is back in the office. Nothing's connected.
Modern punch list tools solve these problems:
- Mobile apps let you create punch list items on site with photos, location, and description all captured in one place. No more transcribing handwritten notes when you get back to the trailer.
- Cloud-based tracking means everyone sees the same current list. Subs can check their open items without asking you. The owner can see progress without waiting for weekly reports.
- Automated notifications alert responsible parties when items are assigned and remind them when deadlines approach.
- Status tracking and reporting show completion percentages and identify bottlenecks at a glance.
Common Punch List Mistakes to Avoid
Creating the punch list too late. Don't wait until the day before the owner's walkthrough. Start your internal list 2-3 weeks before substantial completion.
Being too vague. "Fix bathroom" doesn't help anyone. Specific locations and clear descriptions prevent confusion and ensure work gets done right.
Not taking photos. Photos eliminate "that's how it was" disputes and provide clear documentation of the issue.
Forgetting to assign responsibility. If nobody owns an item, it won't get fixed.
Not verifying completed work. Just because a sub says they're done doesn't mean the work meets spec. Check everything yourself.
Letting the list grow endlessly. The punch list should shrink as you approach final completion, not grow. Control scope creep and don't let new non-deficiency items get added.
The Bottom Line on Punch Lists
A good punch list is detailed, organized, assigned, tracked, and verified. It's not a casual to-do list, it should be the final quality control checkpoint that determines when you get paid and whether the owner is satisfied.
Key takeaways:
- Start early with your own internal walk
- Document every item clearly with location, description, photos, and responsible party
- Assign deadlines and track progress systematically
- Verify completion yourself before bringing the owner back
- Use tools that keep everything organized and visible
The goal is to create a complete, accurate list that gets items fixed efficiently so you can close out the project and move on.
Do it right, and your punch list becomes a project management tool that keeps everyone accountable and ensures quality work. Do it poorly, and you'll be fielding warranty calls for months while subs argue about who's responsible for what.
Your choice.
Managing submittals, and RFIs without the chaos? See how SubmittalLink helps contractors organize closeout documentation. Stop juggling spreadsheets and start managing systematically.